The once-promising platform fighter, Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl, finds itself in a precarious state in 2025. According to recent data, the game has repeatedly dropped below ten concurrent players on Steam, a shocking figure for a title less than four years after its initial launch. This dramatic decline has made online matchmaking across most platforms a significant challenge, with fans reporting painfully long wait times, if they can find a match at all. Is this the final curtain call for the Nickelodeon crossover brawler, or can future updates and promised features like crossplay breathe new life into it?
📉 A Steep and Steady Player Count Decline
The game's struggle is starkly illustrated by its Steam player statistics. Data from SteamDB reveals that in recent months, the game has struggled to maintain a consistent player base, with peak concurrent players in a given month sometimes barely reaching double digits. For comparison, the game launched to impressive numbers for a licensed title in September 2021, boasting a peak of around 13,000 concurrent players on Steam and generating substantial viewership on streaming platforms like Twitch. However, this initial surge was short-lived. By October 2021, that number had already plummeted to approximately 2,700, marking the beginning of a long-term downward trend.
While occasional updates and downloadable content (DLC) releases have provided temporary boosts—such as a spike to 298 players in May 2022—these influxes have failed to translate into lasting player retention. The core issue seems to be a failure to maintain engagement beyond these brief content drops. The player count consistently reverts to its dwindling baseline, leaving the online ecosystem barren.
😔 Community Sentiment: 'The Game Is Dead'
The player statistics are echoed loudly within the game's community. On forums like the official subreddit, long-time fans and newcomers alike express frustration over the inability to play online. One user, Chadwarden1, encapsulated the sentiment, stating, "It's horrible. I apologize if you bought this game recently thinking you could play anyone online." Another user, Metromachine, bluntly agreed, "The game is dead, unfortunately. Steam Charts says only 17 people are playing right now on PC. Switch is probably the same."
This widespread perception of a 'dead' game creates a vicious cycle: new players are deterred from purchasing the game due to fears of an empty online space, while existing players give up trying to find matches, further reducing the active pool. The lack of a robust online player base undermines one of the core appeals of a competitive platform fighter.
🔄 The Elusive Promise of Crossplay
A frequently cited potential solution by the community is the implementation of full cross-platform play (crossplay). This feature, which would allow players on PC, PlayStation, Xbox, and Nintendo Switch to compete together, is seen as the last hope for consolidating the fragmented player base into a single, viable matchmaking pool.
Crossplay was officially confirmed by the developers shortly after launch, with an initial target release window of "early 2022." However, that deadline came and went without the feature's arrival. In the years since, developer focus appears to have shifted toward releasing new DLC characters, which are popular with the dedicated fanbase but do not address the fundamental network infrastructure problem. As of 2025, there has been no substantial update on the crossplay rollout timeline, leaving the community in a state of prolonged anticipation and skepticism.
⚔️ Legacy of Solid Gameplay
Despite its network and population woes, it is important to note that Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl was critically praised for its core mechanics upon release. Many reviews, including a 4/5 score from TheGamer, highlighted its fast-paced, technical combat that drew favorable comparisons to Super Smash Bros. Melee. The game successfully carved out a niche by offering a more mechanically demanding alternative to other platform fighters, with features like wavedashing and a strong emphasis on offensive play.
The roster, featuring beloved Nickelodeon characters from shows like SpongeBob SquarePants, Avatar: The Last Airbender, and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, also provided significant appeal. The subsequent addition of fan-requested fighters like Shredder showed the developers' commitment to expanding the game's universe.
❓ What Does the Future Hold?
The critical question facing Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl in 2025 is whether it can stage a comeback. The path forward likely hinges on a few key factors:
-
Crossplay Implementation: This is the non-negotiable first step. Uniting the player base across all platforms is essential to make online matchmaking functional and appealing again.
-
Sustained Content and Communication: Beyond one-off DLC characters, the game needs a roadmap of consistent updates, balance patches, and new modes to signal ongoing support. Transparent communication from the developers about plans for crossplay and the game's future is crucial to rebuilding community trust.
-
Community Events and Support: Organizing official tournaments, online events, and engaging directly with the remaining dedicated player base could help foster a stronger core community.
In the highly competitive landscape of live-service and fighting games, maintaining momentum is incredibly difficult. Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl serves as a case study in how a well-designed game with strong initial interest can falter without a sustainable plan for long-term engagement and essential quality-of-life features. The bones of a great fighter are there, but without the necessary support systems, its online arenas may remain empty. Will 2025 be the year the developers finally deliver on their promises and revive this nostalgic brawler, or will it be remembered as a missed opportunity? Only time, and perhaps a crucial crossplay update, will tell.